Find your local Preferred Mutual independent agent and get a quote for home, auto or business insurance in New York, New Hampshire, New Jersey or Massachusetts.

Preferred Mutual offers home insurance, auto insurance and business insurance. Learn how to get a free quote at Preferredmutual.com.

New York auto insurance from Preferred Mutual offers auto insurance in NY with coverage options on everything from basic liability, collision, to comprehensive.

Find the best Massachusetts car insurance policy and coverage options for you! See our auto insurance discounts and policy options, and find a local MA car insurance agent to get a quote.

Preferred Mutual provides insurance for all your personal needs including auto insurance, homeowner’s insurance and other coverages such as renter’s, boat, umbrella and valuable …

Life is busy! Preferred Mutual's Mobile App lets you easily manage your policy anywhere, at any time!

Learn more about Preferred Mutual Insurance Company and what differentiates us. We strive to exceed expectations of our policyholders, agents and employees.

Depending on the nature of your claim, you can expect certain forms, letters or updates on your claim from Preferred Mutual. Use this website to answer any common questions, print copies …

Part of living assured is having the knowledge and resources needed to make confident choices regarding your insurance needs. Preferred Mutual has the answers to some common …

Contact Preferred Mutual today with questions or inquiries. Call us at 800-333-7642. Preferred Mutual provides home, auto and business insurance in NY, MA, NJ and NH.